Consultation display
Senedd Cymru (Members and Elections) Bill
- This consultation has completed. It ran from Thursday, 21 September 2023 to Friday, 3 November 2023
- View the background to this consultation
- View all current consultations
Purpose of the consultation
The Senedd Cymru (Members and Elections) Bill has been referred to the Reform Bill Committee for Stage 1 scrutiny of the general principles of the Bill.
The information on this page provides more detail about what the Committee is looking at and how you can share your views. All of the information is also available to download as a Microsoft Word document. Information about how to use the accessibility options in the Microsoft Word version is available in an explainer document.
Terms of reference
To help inform its scrutiny, the Committee asked for views on:
>>>>
>>>The general principles of the Senedd Cymru (Members and Elections) (Wales) Bill and whether there is a need for legislation to deliver the Bill’s stated policy objectives (see below for further information about the Bill).
>>>Any potential barriers to the implementation of the Bill’s provisions, and whether the Bill and accompanying Explanatory Memorandum and Regulatory Impact Assessment take adequate account of them.
>>>Whether there are any unintended consequences arising from the Bill.
>>>The Welsh Government’s assessment of the financial and other impacts of the Bill as set out in Parts 2 and 3 of the Explanatory Memorandum.
>>>The appropriateness of the powers in the Bill for Welsh Ministers to make subordinate legislation (as set out in Part 1: Chapter 5 of the Explanatory Memorandum).
>>>Matters relating to the competence of the Senedd including compatibility with the European Convention on Human Rights.
>>>The balance between the information contained on the face of the Bill and what is left to subordinate legislation.
>>>Any matter related to the quality of the legislation.
>>>Any other matter related to the constitutional or other implications of the Bill.
<<<<
The deadline for submissions to this consultation was Friday 3 November 2023.
We received a large number of responses to this consultation. We are in the process of working through the responses received to date and will be publishing them on a regular basis. If you have responded and it has not yet appeared please be assured that we are currently working on it.
Information about the Bill
If passed, the Senedd Cymru (Members and Elections) Bill will:
>>>>
>>>Increase the size of the Senedd to 96 Members.
>>>Decrease the length of time between Senedd ordinary general elections from five to four years.
>>>Increase the maximum number of Deputy Presiding Officers from one to two.
>>>Increase the legislative limit on the size of the Welsh Government to 17 (plus the First Minister and Counsel General), with power to further increase the limit to 18 or 19.
>>>Require candidates to, and Members of, the Senedd to be resident in Wales (by disqualifying candidates and Members who are not registered to vote in a Senedd constituency).
>>>Provide a mechanism for the Seventh Senedd’s consideration of job-sharing of offices relating to the Senedd (by requiring the Llywydd in the Seventh Senedd to propose the establishment of a Senedd committee to review specified matters).
>>>Change the Senedd’s electoral system so that all Members are elected via closed list proportional representation, with votes translated into seats via the D’Hondt formula.
>>>Repurpose and rename the Local Democracy and Boundary Commission for Wales; provide the renamed Democracy and Boundary Commission Cymru (DBCC) with the functions needed to establish new Senedd constituencies and undertake ongoing reviews of Senedd constituency boundaries; and provide instructions for the DBCC to follow when undertaking boundary reviews.
>>>Provide for review of the operation and effect of the new legislative provisions following the 2026 election (by requiring the Llywydd after the election to propose the establishment of a Senedd committee to review specified matters).
<<<<
Supporting documents
- Responses from organisations and people responding in a professional capacity
- SCME(P)1 - Alan Renwick
PDF 300 KB
- SCME(P)2 - Llywydd
PDF 418 KB
- SCME(P)3 - The Association of Electoral Administrators
PDF 963 KB
- SCME(P)4 - Alistair Clark
PDF 284 KB
- SCME(P)5 - Electoral Reform Society Cymru
PDF 379 KB
- SCME(P)6 - Welsh Language Commissioner
PDF 1 MB
- SCME(P)7 - Jac Larner
PDF 392 KB
- SCME(P)8 - Boundaries Scotland
PDF 222 KB
- SCME(P)9 - The Electoral Commission
PDF 280 KB
- SCME(P)10 - Women’s Equality Network Cymru
PDF 367 KB
- SCME(P)11 - Solace Wales
PDF 762 KB
- SCME(P)12 - Wales Electoral Coordination Board
PDF 260 KB
- SCME(P)13 - Public and Commercial Services union
PDF 383 KB
- SCME(P)14 - Electoral Management Board for Scotland
PDF 319 KB
- SCME(P)15 - Audit Wales
PDF 230 KB
- SCME(P)16 - Rhys ab Owen
PDF 281 KB
- SCME(P)17 - Mike Hedges
PDF 141 KB
- SCME(P)18 - Keith Bush
PDF 307 KB
- SCME(P)19 - David Hughes
PDF 89 KB
- SCME(P)20 - Local Democracy and Boundary Commission for Wales
PDF 516 KB
- SCME(P)21 - Thomas Glyn Watkin
PDF 205 KB
- SCME(P)22 - James Gilmour
PDF 286 KB
- SCME(P)23 - Institute of Welsh Affairs
PDF 277 KB
- SCME(P)24 - Flintshire County Council
PDF 798 KB
- SCME(P)25 - UNISON
PDF 155 KB
- SCME(P)26 - Cymdeithas Cymru (English Translation by Senedd Commission)
PDF 871 KB
- SCME(P)27 - Wales Environment Link
PDF 536 KB
- SCME(P)28 - Denis Mollison
PDF 1 MB
- SCME(P)29 - Welsh Local Government Association
PDF 1 MB
- Responses from people responding in an individual capacity
- SCME01 - Robert Jenkins
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (32) 10 KB
- SCME02 - Annemarie Bevan Edwards
PDF 367 KB View as HTML (33) 14 KB
- SCME03 - Jeremy Miles
PDF 369 KB View as HTML (34) 14 KB
- SCME04 - Peter Weavers
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (35) 10 KB
- SCME05 - Vicky Moller
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (36) 11 KB
- SCME06 - Gordon Davies
PDF 353 KB View as HTML (37) 9 KB
- SCME07 - Elwyn Currier
PDF 389 KB View as HTML (38) 13 KB
- SCME08 - Gillian Bruce
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (39) 10 KB
- SCME09 - Gerald Black
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (40) 10 KB
- SCME10 - Jane O'Neill
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (41) 10 KB
- SCME11 - Dave Llewllyn
PDF 352 KB View as HTML (42) 9 KB
- SCME12 - Stu Emberlin
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (43) 9 KB
- SCME13 - Sandra Wheeler
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (44) 9 KB
- SCME14 - Ross Evans
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (45) 10 KB
- SCME15 - Individual
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (46) 10 KB
- SCME16 - David Evans
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (47) 10 KB
- SCME17 - Christopher Poole
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (48) 10 KB
- SCME18 - Stephen Lawrenson
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (49) 9 KB
- SCME19 - Wayne Staniland
PDF 379 KB View as HTML (50) 10 KB
- SCME20 - Robert Jones
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (51) 10 KB
- SCME21 - Jamie Standing
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (52) 10 KB
- SCME22 - A Graham
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (53) 9 KB
- SCME23 - A Coles
PDF 366 KB View as HTML (54) 10 KB
- SCME24 - J.G.Cuffe
PDF 386 KB View as HTML (55) 10 KB
- SCME25 - Helen Cowan
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (56) 9 KB
- SCME26 - Terina Thomas
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (57) 10 KB
- SCME27 - Nick Baker
PDF 377 KB View as HTML (58) 10 KB
- SCME28 - Jan Adkins
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (59) 10 KB
- SCME29 - Wendy Massey
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (60) 9 KB
- SCME30 - Mrs L Sargent
PDF 369 KB View as HTML (61) 13 KB
- SCME31 - Kris Lloyd
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (62) 10 KB
- SCME32 - James Smith
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (63) 9 KB
- SCME33 - Karen Nixon
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (64) 10 KB
- SCME34 - Helen George
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (65) 9 KB
- SCME35 - Individual
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (66) 10 KB
- SCME36 - David Gill
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (67) 10 KB
- SCME37 - Sharon Edwards
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (68) 10 KB
- SCME38 - Peter Griffin
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (69) 9 KB
- SCME39 - Leon Williams
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (70) 10 KB
- SCME40 - Hewan Ormson
PDF 411 KB View as HTML (71) 18 KB
- SCME41 - Jennifer Whitlock
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (72) 9 KB
- SCME42 - John Gallanders
PDF 370 KB View as HTML (73) 15 KB
- SCME43 - Individual
PDF 465 KB View as HTML (74) 18 KB
- SCME44 - Paul Spearman
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (75) 9 KB
- SCME45 - Individual
PDF 349 KB View as HTML (76) 10 KB
- SCME46 - Anthony Gullick
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (77) 9 KB
- SCME47 - Michael Hooton
PDF 367 KB View as HTML (78) 13 KB
- SCME48 - Paul Rabone
PDF 367 KB View as HTML (79) 11 KB
- SCME49 - Michelle Williams
PDF 521 KB View as HTML (80) 14 KB
- SCME50 - David Rees
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (81) 9 KB
- SCME51 - Individuals
PDF 370 KB View as HTML (82) 10 KB
- SCME52 - David Jones
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (83) 9 KB
- SCME53 - Wendy Beever
PDF 400 KB View as HTML (84) 13 KB
- SCME54 - James Haley
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (85) 10 KB
- SCME55 - Les Cox
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (86) 9 KB
- SCME56 - Raymond Mainwaring
PDF 351 KB View as HTML (87) 9 KB
- SCME57 - Alan Phillips
PDF 352 KB View as HTML (88) 9 KB
- SCME58 - Gary Jones
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (89) 10 KB
- SCME59 - Individual
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (90) 9 KB
- SCME60 - Paul Jones
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (91) 9 KB
- SCME61 - Marilyn Forster
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (92) 10 KB
- SCME62 - AK Thomas
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (93) 10 KB
- SCME63 - Lianne Balint
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (94) 9 KB
- SCME64 - Glen Smith
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (95) 10 KB
- SCME65 - Michael A. Wood
PDF 364 KB View as HTML (96) 10 KB
- SCME66 - James Amos
PDF 362 KB View as HTML (97) 9 KB
- SCME67 - Jayne Dingle
PDF 365 KB View as HTML (98) 10 KB
- SCME68 - Tracy Tappenden
PDF 378 KB View as HTML (99) 15 KB
- SCME69 - Brian Harrison
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (100) 9 KB
- SCME70 - Linda Edger
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (101) 10 KB
- SCME71 - Robert Watkins
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (102) 10 KB
- SCME72 - Lynne Bond
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (103) 10 KB
- SCME73 - Hywel Evans
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (104) 9 KB
- SCME74 - Individual
PDF 243 KB
- SCME75 - Tracey Shilling
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (106) 10 KB
- SCME76 - Gareth Morris
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (107) 10 KB
- SCME77 - San Jones
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (108) 10 KB
- SCME78 - Kevin Ackerman
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (109) 9 KB
- SCME79 - Jane Young
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (110) 9 KB
- SCME80 - Individual
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (111) 10 KB
- SCME81 - Andrew Wood
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (112) 10 KB
- SCME82 - Mick Randall
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (113) 9 KB
- SCME83 - Barney Procter
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (114) 9 KB
- SCME84 - Jane Richards
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (115) 10 KB
- SCME85 - Allan Keating
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (116) 10 KB
- SCME86 - Rob Travers
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (117) 9 KB
- SCME87 - Nigel Harding
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (118) 9 KB
- SCME88 - Margaret Bridge
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (119) 10 KB
- SCME89 - Paul Gillam
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (120) 9 KB
- SCME90 - Jeff Davies
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (121) 10 KB
- SCME91 - Michael Sands
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (122) 9 KB
- SCME92 - John Williams
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (123) 9 KB
- SCME93 - Margaret Davies
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (124) 10 KB
- SCME94 - Emma Atkinson
PDF 353 KB View as HTML (125) 9 KB
- SCME95 - Richard Ivey
PDF 365 KB View as HTML (126) 10 KB
- SCME96 - Julie Powell
PDF 304 KB View as HTML (127) 8 KB
- SCME97 - Nigel Astley
PDF 349 KB View as HTML (128) 11 KB
- SCME98 - Nicholas Bolton
PDF 383 KB View as HTML (129) 12 KB
- SCME99 - Christina Davies
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (130) 10 KB
- SCME100 - Jason Atkinson
PDF 347 KB View as HTML (131) 10 KB
- SCME101 - Antony Coakley
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (132) 10 KB
- SCME102 - Steven Edwards
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (133) 9 KB
- SCME103- Irene Hunt
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (134) 10 KB
- SCME104 - Sharron Harries
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (135) 11 KB
- SCME105 - Brian James
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (136) 10 KB
- SCME106 - Alan Roberts
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (137) 10 KB
- SCME107- Helen E Oliver
PDF 409 KB View as HTML (138) 12 KB
- SCME108 - Marta Jacyna
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (139) 10 KB
- SCME109 - Paulette Gough
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (140) 9 KB
- SCME110 - Michael Smith
PDF 353 KB View as HTML (141) 9 KB
- SCME111 - Eurona Phillips
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (142) 9 KB
- SCME112 - Kev James
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (143) 10 KB
- SCME113 - Valerie Jones
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (144) 7 KB
- SCME114 - Jenna Morgan
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (145) 6 KB
- SCME115 - Individual
PDF 368 KB View as HTML (146) 8 KB
- SCME116 - Individual
PDF 362 KB View as HTML (147) 6 KB
- SCME117 - Georgine Dorgan
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (148) 5 KB
- SCME118 - Mark Eversfield
PDF 384 KB View as HTML (149) 6 KB
- SCME119 - David Daniels
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (150) 6 KB
- SCME120 - Alan Parker
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (151) 6 KB
- SCME121 - Individual
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (152) 9 KB
- SCME122 - Mark Ball
PDF 362 KB View as HTML (153) 12 KB
- SCME123 - Nicola Buttland
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (154) 9 KB
- SCME124 - Andy Brown
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (155) 10 KB
- SCME125 - John Valentine
PDF 362 KB View as HTML (156) 11 KB
- SCME126 - Roz Stirman
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (157) 9 KB
- SCME127 - David Hawkins
PDF 351 KB View as HTML (158) 9 KB
- SCME128 - Hugh Stokes
PDF 350 KB View as HTML (159) 9 KB
- SCME129 - Andrew Pritchard
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (160) 9 KB
- SCME130 - Keith Pritchard
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (161) 9 KB
- SCME131 - John Stowe
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (162) 10 KB
- SCME132 - Mark Careless
PDF 362 KB View as HTML (163) 10 KB
- SCME133 - Robert Jones
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (164) 9 KB
- SCME134 - Paul Nicholas
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (165) 10 KB
- SCME135 - David Maas
PDF 369 KB View as HTML (166) 11 KB
- SCME136 - Steve Bowen
PDF 370 KB View as HTML (167) 12 KB
- SCME137 - Eileen Abako
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (168) 11 KB
- SCME138 - Nigel Hynes
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (169) 10 KB
- SCME139 - Noreen Macgillivray
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (170) 10 KB
- SCME140 - Graham Hadlow
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (171) 9 KB
- SCME141 - Gill Worthing
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (172) 9 KB
- SCME142 - Louise Witter
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (173) 9 KB
- SCME143 - Nevena Flatters
PDF 362 KB View as HTML (174) 10 KB
- SCME144 - Mike Howard
PDF 353 KB View as HTML (175) 9 KB
- SCME145 - Thomas McGrane
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (176) 10 KB
- SCME146 - Lynne Carver
PDF 363 KB View as HTML (177) 10 KB
- SCME147 - Chris Connolly
PDF 350 KB View as HTML (178) 9 KB
- SCME148 - David L Williams
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (179) 10 KB
- SCME149 - Sid Thomas
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (180) 9 KB
- SCME150 - Paul Raven
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (181) 10 KB
- SCME151 - Dorian Molumby
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (182) 9 KB
- SCME152 - Martin Fisher
PDF 449 KB View as HTML (183) 11 KB
- SCME154 - Christina Owen
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (184) 9 KB
- SCME155 - Katharine Lee
PDF 355 KB View as HTML (185) 9 KB
- SCME156 - John Bishop
PDF 354 KB View as HTML (186) 9 KB
- SCME157 - Wendy FIsher
PDF 365 KB View as HTML (187) 11 KB
- SCME158 - Paula Miles
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (188) 10 KB
- SCME159 - Brian Berry
PDF 356 KB View as HTML (189) 9 KB
- SCME160 - Alyson Thomas
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (190) 10 KB
- SCME161 - Mike Fox
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (191) 10 KB
- SCME162 - Jonathan Faull
PDF 350 KB View as HTML (192) 12 KB
- SCME163 - Andy
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (193) 9 KB
- SCME164 - Terence Mullarkey
PDF 424 KB View as HTML (194) 10 KB
- SCME165 - Elaine Evans
PDF 363 KB View as HTML (195) 10 KB
- SCME166 - Tom
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (196) 10 KB
- SCME167 - Nick Morgan
PDF 368 KB View as HTML (197) 12 KB
- SCME168 - Wynne Hughes
PDF 363 KB View as HTML (198) 10 KB
- SCME169 - Averil Matthews
PDF 363 KB View as HTML (199) 11 KB
- SCME170 - Dawn Shenton
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (200) 9 KB
- SCME171 - Alan Matthews
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (201) 12 KB
- SCME172 - Individuals
PDF 377 KB View as HTML (202) 11 KB
- SCME173 - Nigel Cuttell
PDF 358 KB View as HTML (203) 10 KB
- SCME174 - Stephen Starr
PDF 368 KB View as HTML (204) 11 KB
- SCME175 - Darren
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (205) 9 KB
- SCME176 - Paul Williams
PDF 369 KB View as HTML (206) 10 KB
- SCME177 - John Evans
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (207) 9 KB
- SCME178 - Anthony Cacicia
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (208) 10 KB
- SCME179 - Tony Brown
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (209) 9 KB
- SCME180 - John Heppenstall
PDF 367 KB View as HTML (210) 11 KB
- SCME181 - Tracy Sheridan
PDF 362 KB View as HTML (211) 10 KB
- SCME182 - Evelyn Shepherd
PDF 359 KB View as HTML (212) 9 KB
- SCME183 - Mark Lanchbury
PDF 362 KB View as HTML (213) 10 KB
- SCME184 - Richard Lloyd
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (214) 10 KB
- SCME185 - Nigel Hammond
PDF 363 KB View as HTML (215) 12 KB
- SCME186 - Gwynn Parry
PDF 553 KB View as HTML (216) 12 KB
- SCME187 - Dave Facer
PDF 379 KB View as HTML (217) 11 KB
- SCME188 - Dorothy Brooks
PDF 360 KB View as HTML (218) 10 KB
- SCME189 - Tim Conway
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (219) 10 KB
- SCME190 - Individual
PDF 381 KB View as HTML (220) 12 KB
- SCME191 - Individual
PDF 370 KB View as HTML (221) 10 KB
- SCME192 - Carl Willett
PDF 361 KB View as HTML (222) 11 KB
- SCME193 - David Holmes
PDF 628 KB View as HTML (223) 13 KB
- SCME194 - Andrew Mayes
PDF 357 KB View as HTML (224) 9 KB