Meetings
Inquiry into medical recruitment
This page gives details of any meetings held which will, or did, discuss the matter, and includes links to the relevant Papers, Agendas and Minutes.
Note: Meeting Agenda can change at short notice. Particularly where future meeting dates are indicated more than a week in advance. Please check before planning to attend a Committee Meeting that the item you are interested in has not been moved.
Meeting: 11/01/2018 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 3)
- Webcast for 11/01/2018 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd
- Transcript for 11/01/2018 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd
3 Inquiry into medical recruitment - letter from the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Well-being and Sport to the Chair of the Committee regarding GP Training Incentives
Supporting documents:
Minutes:
3.6a
The Committee noted the letter from the Cabinet Secretary for Health,
Well-being and Sport to the Chair of the Committee regarding GP Training
Incentives.
Meeting: 11/10/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 4)
4 Letter from the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Well-being and Sport regarding Health Education and Improvement Wales (HEIW)
Supporting documents:
Minutes:
4.2a
The Committee noted the letter from the Cabinet Secretary for Health,
Well-being and Sport in relation to Health Education and Improvement Wales.
Meeting: 21/09/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 6)
6 Letter from the Royal College of General Practitioners following the report launch
Supporting documents:
Minutes:
6.4a
The Committee noted the letter from the Royal College of General Practitioners
in relation to the launch of the Committee’s report on medical recruitment.
Meeting: 20/09/2017 - Plenary - Fifth Senedd (Item 5)
Debate on the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee's report on medical recruitment
NDM6502 Dai
Lloyd (South Wales West)
To propose that the National Assembly for Wales:
Notes the report of the Health, Social Care and Sport
Committee on the inquiry into medical recruitment, which was laid
in the Table Office on 29 June 2017.
Note: The response of the Cabinet Secretary for
Health, Well-being and Sport to the report was laid
in the Table Office on 13 September 2017.
Minutes:
The item started at 15.49
NDM6502 Dai Lloyd (South Wales West)
To propose that the National Assembly for
Wales:
Notes the report of the Health, Social Care
and Sport Committee on the inquiry into medical recruitment.
The motion was agreed in accordance with Standing Order 12.36.
Meeting: 07/06/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 6)
6 Inquiry into medical recruitment - consideration of draft report (2)
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 17 , View reasons restricted (6/1)
Minutes:
6.1
The Committee agreed the report subject to minor amendments.
Meeting: 25/05/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 8)
8 Inquiry into medical recruitment - consideration of draft report
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 21 , View reasons restricted (8/1)
Minutes:
8.1
The Committee considered a first draft of the report of its inquiry into
medical recruitment.
Meeting: 17/05/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 4)
4 Report from Sian Gwenllian AM on 'Tackling the Crisis - a new medical school for Wales'
Supporting documents:
Minutes:
4.1a
The Committee noted the report from Sian Gwenllian AM.
Meeting: 15/03/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 5)
Inquiry into medical recruitment - consideration of evidence and discussion of the key issues arising from scrutiny
Minutes:
5.1
The Committee discussed the key issues that have arisen during scrutiny of its Inquiry
into medical recruitment ahead of the preparation of its draft report.
Meeting: 15/03/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 2)
2 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 10 - Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Sport
Vaughan
Gething AM, Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Sport
Dr
Frank Atherton, Chief Medical Officer
Julie
Rogers, Director of Workforce & Organisation Development
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 31 , View reasons restricted (2/1)
- Paper 1 - Submission from the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Well-being and Sport, item 2 PDF 549 KB
Minutes:
2.1
The Committee received evidence from the Cabinet Secretary for Health,
Wellbeing and Sport, the Chief Medical Officer and the Director of Workforce
& Organisation Development.
2.2
The Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Sport agreed to provide the
Committee with numbers from the first round of GP training places.
Meeting: 09/03/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 2)
2 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 10 - the medical schools in Wales
Professor
Keith Lloyd, Dean of Swansea University Medical School
Dr
Stephen Riley, Dean of Cardiff University Medical School
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 36 , View reasons restricted (2/1)
- Paper 1 – Submission from Swansea University, item 2 PDF 300 KB View as HTML (2/2) 27 KB
- Paper 2 – Supplementary submission from Professor Keith Lloyd, item 2 PDF 358 KB View as HTML (2/3) 34 KB
- Paper 3 – Submission from Cardiff University, item 2 PDF 741 KB
Minutes:
2.1
The Committee received evidence from representatives from Swansea University
Medical School and Cardiff University Medical School.
Meeting: 09/03/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 4)
4 Inquiry into medical recruitment - additional information from BMA Cymru Wales
Supporting documents:
Minutes:
4.1
The Committee noted the additional information from BMA Cymru Wales.
Meeting: 09/03/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 6)
Inquiry into medical recruitment - consideration of evidence
Minutes:
6.1
The Committee discussed the evidence given during item 2 of the meeting.
Meeting: 16/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 3)
3 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 7 - Royal College of Psychiatrists and the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health
Professor
Keith Lloyd, Royal College of Psychiatrists
Dr
M Sakheer Kunnath, Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health
Supporting documents:
- Paper 4 - Submission from the Royal College of Psychiatrists, item 3 PDF 138 KB View as HTML (3/1) 35 KB
- Paper 5 - Submission from the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, item 3 PDF 233 KB View as HTML (3/2) 41 KB
Minutes:
3.1
The Committee received evidence from representatives of the Royal College of
Psychiatrists and the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health.
Meeting: 16/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 2)
2 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 6 - Royal College of Emergency Medicine and the Royal College of Radiologists
Dr
Amanda Farrow, Head of School, Royal College of Emergency Medicine Wales
Dr
Robin Roop, Vice President, Royal College of Emergency Medicine Wales
Dr
Martin Rolles, Chairman of the Standing Welsh Committee, Royal College of
Radiologists
Dr
Toby Wells, Secretary, Royal College of Radiologists
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 54 , View reasons restricted (2/1)
- Paper 1 - Submission from the Royal College of Emergency Medicine Wales, item 2 PDF 164 KB View as HTML (2/2) 87 KB
- Paper 2 - Submission from Dr Martin Rolles, item 2 PDF 380 KB View as HTML (2/3) 26 KB
- Paper 3 - Submission from Dr Toby Wells, item 2 PDF 337 KB View as HTML (2/4) 59 KB
Minutes:
2.1
The Committee received evidence from representatives of the Royal College of
Emergency Medicine and the Royal College of Radiologists.
Meeting: 16/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 7)
Inquiry into medical recruitment - consideration of evidence
Minutes:
7.1
The Committee discussed the evidence given during items 2, 3, 4 and 5.
Meeting: 16/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 5)
5 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 9 - Wales Deanery
Professor
Peter Donnelly, Interim Postgraduate Dean
Dr
Phil Matthews, Deputy Director of General Practice/Head of Specialty Training
School for General Practice
Dr
Helen Baker, Associate Director (Secondary Care)
Supporting documents:
Minutes:
5.1
The Committee received evidence from representatives of the Wales Deanery.
Meeting: 16/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 4)
4 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 8 - Local Health Boards
Professor
Peter Barrett-Lee, Medical Director, Velindre NHS Trust
Martin
Jones, Executive Director of Workforce and Organisational Development, Betsi
Cadwaladr University Health Board
Dr
Evan Moore, Medical Director, Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board
Sharon
Vickery, Head of HR Delivery Unit & Medical Staffing, Abertawe Bro
Morgannwg University Health Board
Dr
Philip Kloer, Medical Director, Hywel Dda University Health Board
Supporting documents:
- Paper 6 - Submission from the Welsh NHS Confederation and NHS Wales Employers, item 4 PDF 301 KB View as HTML (4/1) 117 KB
Minutes:
4.1
The Committee received evidence from representatives of Velindre NHS Trust, Betsi
Cadwaladr University Health Board, Abertawe Bro Morgannwg University Health
Board and Hywel Dda University Health Board.
Meeting: 08/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 2)
2 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 3 - BMA Cymru Wales and Royal College of Physicians
Dr
Charlotte Jones, Chair of the BMA’s General Practitioners Committee (Wales)
Dr
Trevor Pickersgill, Chair of the BMA’s Welsh Consultants Committee
Dr
Gareth Llewelyn FRCP, RCP vice president for Wales
Lowri
Jackson, RCP senior policy and public affairs adviser for Wales
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 71 , View reasons restricted (2/1)
- Paper 1 – Submission from BMA Cymru Wales, item 2 PDF 238 KB View as HTML (2/2) 46 KB
- Paper 2 – Submission from Royal College of Physicians, item 2 PDF 1 MB
Minutes:
2.1
The Committee received evidence from representatives of BMA Cymru Wales and the
Royal College of Physicians.
2.2
Dr Jones agreed to provide the Committee with a paper addressing crown
indemnity and the Welsh Risk Pool.
Meeting: 08/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 4)
Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 5 - Professor Dean Williams
Professor
Dean Williams, Bangor Medical School
Minutes:
4.1
The Committee received evidence from Professor Williams.
Meeting: 08/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 7)
Inquiry into medical recruitment - consideration of evidence
Minutes:
7.1
The Committee discussed the evidence given during items 2, 3 and 4.
Meeting: 08/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 3)
3 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 4 - Royal College of General Practitioners and GP Survival
Dr
Rebecca Payne, Royal College of General Practitioners
Dr
Isolde Shore-Nye, Royal College of General Practitioners
Dr
Linda Dykes, Consultant in Emergency Medicine, Ysbyty Gwynedd and GPwSI in
Community Geriatrics, BCUHB (West)
Dr
Sara Bodey, GP partner Bradley's Practice, Buckley, Flintshire (GP Survival)
Dr
Heidi Phillips, GP Partner Fforestfach Medical Centre, Swansea and Director of
Admissions for Swansea Graduate Entry Medicine programme (GP Survival)
Supporting documents:
- Paper 3 – Submission from Royal College of General Practitioners, item 3 PDF 109 KB View as HTML (3/1) 13 KB
- Paper 4 – Submission from GP Survival, item 3 PDF 282 KB
- Paper 5 – Submission from Dr Linda Dykes, item 3 PDF 10 MB
- Paper 6 – Submission from Dr Sara Bodey (GP Survival), item 3 PDF 241 KB View as HTML (3/4) 25 KB
- Paper 7 – Submission from Dr Heidi Phillips (GP Survival), item 3 PDF 840 KB
Minutes:
3.1
The Committee received evidence from representatives of the Royal College of General
Practitioners, GP Survival, and from Dr Linda Dykes.
Meeting: 02/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 3)
Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 2 - Trainee panel
Dr
Llion Davies
Dr
Zahid Khan
Dr
Abby Parish
Dr
Bethan Roberts
Dr
Huw Lloyd Williams
Minutes:
3.1
The Committee received evidence from Dr Llion Davies, Dr Zahid Khan, Dr Abby
Parish, Dr Bethan Roberts and Dr Huw Lloyd Williams.
Meeting: 02/02/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 2)
2 Inquiry into medical recruitment - evidence session 1 - Professor Robin Williams
Professor
Robin Williams, author of ‘Health
Professional Education Investment – Report on the Single Set of Arrangements’
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 91 , View reasons restricted (2/1)
Minutes:
2.1
The Committee received evidence from Professor Robin Williams.
Meeting: 11/01/2017 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 5)
5 Correspondence from the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Well-being and Sport regarding the establishment of Health Education Wales
Supporting documents:
Minutes:
5.4a
The Committee noted the letter from the Cabinet Secretary for Health,
Well-being and Sport regarding the establishment of Health Education Wales.
Meeting: 01/12/2016 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 11)
11 Inquiry into medical recruitment - preparation for taking evidence
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 99 , View reasons restricted (11/1)
- Cover, item 11 PDF 2 MB
- contents, item 11 PDF 26 KB View as HTML (11/2) 28 KB
- MR 01 Phil Jones, item 11 PDF 21 KB View as HTML (11/3) 10 KB
- MR 02 Dr Adam Dallmann, item 11 PDF 19 KB View as HTML (11/4) 17 KB
- MR 03 Dr Geraint Morris, item 11 PDF 21 KB View as HTML (11/5) 11 KB
- MR 04 Andrew Davies, item 11 PDF 17 KB View as HTML (11/6) 7 KB
- MR 05 Royal College of Nursing Wales, item 11 PDF 27 KB View as HTML (11/7) 13 KB
- MR 06 Wales Deanery, item 11 PDF 71 KB View as HTML (11/8) 59 KB
- MR 07 Royal College of Physicians Edinburgh, item 11 PDF 58 KB View as HTML (11/9) 23 KB
- MR 08 Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, item 11 PDF 80 KB View as HTML (11/10) 40 KB
- MR 09 Royal College of General Practitioners, item 11 PDF 23 KB View as HTML (11/11) 12 KB
- MR 10 Age Cymru, item 11 PDF 91 KB View as HTML (11/12) 25 KB
- MR 11 Dr Kate Gower Thomas BSc, MB BCh, FRCR, item 11 PDF 56 KB View as HTML (11/13) 23 KB
- MR 12 Aneurin Bevan University Health Board, item 11 PDF 74 KB View as HTML (11/14) 24 KB
- MR 13 Cardiff University School of Medicine, item 11 PDF 36 KB View as HTML (11/15) 20 KB
- MR 14 Royal College of Physicians, item 11 PDF 52 KB View as HTML (11/16) 37 KB
- MR 14 Royal College of Physicians Annex 1, item 11 PDF 681 KB
- MR 15 Royal College of Emergency Medicine Wales, item 11 PDF 88 KB View as HTML (11/18) 86 KB
- MR 16 Awen Iorwerth (Welsh only), item 11 PDF 30 KB View as HTML (11/19) 28 KB
- Restricted enclosure 119 , View reasons restricted (11/20)
- MR 17 Public Health Wales, item 11 PDF 55 KB View as HTML (11/21) 24 KB
- MR 18 Royal Pharmaceutical Society, item 11 PDF 25 KB View as HTML (11/22) 13 KB
- MR 19 Bliss, item 11 PDF 79 KB View as HTML (11/23) 33 KB
- MR 20 British Medical Association (Wales), item 11 PDF 90 KB View as HTML (11/24) 46 KB
- MR 21 Welsh NHS Confederation and NHS Wales Employers, item 11 PDF 127 KB View as HTML (11/25) 117 KB
- MR 22 Royal College of Phychiatrists, item 11 PDF 47 KB View as HTML (11/26) 34 KB
- Endsheet, item 11 PDF 17 KB
Minutes:
11.1
The Committee had further discussions about its inquiry into medical recruitment
and agreed to issue invites to stakeholders to attend evidence gathering
sessions in the Spring.
Meeting: 13/10/2016 - Health, Social Care and Sport Committee - Fifth Senedd (Item 3)
3 Inquiry into medical recruitment - Preparation for visit to the School of Medicine at Cardiff University
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 130 , View reasons restricted (3/1)
Minutes:
3.1
The Committee visited the School of Medicine at Cardiff University as part of
its inquiry into medical recruitment.