P-05-842 Give young people a voice when commissioning local services in Wales
This petition was submitted by the Changing Minds Campaign Group, having collected 1,387 signatures online and 2,865 on paper, a total of 4,252 signatures.
Text of Petition
call on the National Assembly for Wales to urge the Welsh Government to
acknowledge that the current level of young persons’ participation in the
commissioning of services does not allow for the inclusion of marginalised
groups. We request a review of the policies and guidance in place and a
recommendation that new guidelines are mandatory for services commissioned to
work with young people.
Every young person in Wales needs to be able to share their voice and experience in a way that is meaningful to them, to shape the services that are available to support them. We are asking for your support to promote changes to achieve this goal. As young people we must be able to share our thoughts and views on the projects that we need in our area.
only youth councils/ forums are consulted- which is not representative of those
who struggle to attend such forums such as those 1 in 5 young adults who have a
diagnosable mental health disorder. There needs to be a platform for those
young people who may not be able to participate in the current schemes due to
their mental health to share their opinions on services and projects that are directly
affecting them. We are a group of young people that have been involved in the
Changing Minds Project coordinated by Newport Mind, which is due to lose
funding in November of this year. Because of this we have been learning about
the commissioning process, which has led to this petition being created and to
our wider #changeit campaign. Direct inclusion of young people with mental
health issues in the commissioning process will allow for greater tailoring of
service provisions and improve confidence in the services amongst the targeted
“Involvement in this project enabled me to really understand the concerns of young people and the issues they face. Without these concerns being raised and included from the inception of any policy which affects them, any initiative affecting young people will be flawed".
The Children’s Rights Approach in Wales by the Children’s Commissioner for Wales outlines a framework for embedding children’s rights within services working with young people. These are guidelines and thus non-binding. Based on the United Nations Convention for the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) Article 12 outlines the right of children to be involved within policies creation and implementation; particularly those which affect their demographic. The Children’s Commissioner for Wales Annual Report for the 2016/2017 year (the Report) specifically highlights the Commissioner’s wish to see greater integration of young people within the commissioning process. The current guidelines for youth participation in Wales are, amongst other sources, contained within the Children and Young People’s Participation in Wales Good Practice Guide 2016. The seven ‘Core Standards’ contained within the Guide are excellent starting steps. We feel that the non-mandatory nature of these standards and approaches, although partly met within some authorities in Wales, are insufficient for ensuring accountability for all services working with young people. We seek to ensure that young people from marginalised groups have a voice in the decision making processes as well as ensuring that service provision for young people all over Wales are of a similarly excellent standard. Our petition is in line with Recommendation 10 of the Mind over Matter report that highlights the current levels of provision of mental health services for young people, and compliments the work by the Together for Children and Young People Programme. Without change to the current guidelines, young people across Wales will continue to be marginalised. Specifically, those with mental health issues or additional needs who may not be able to take part in the current – and limited – youth participation initiatives will continue to find it difficult to voice their opinions.
This petition was considered completed by the Petitions Committee at its meeting on 07/01/2020.
The Committee considered further correspondence and agreed that there appears to be little further that it could achieve at this time, given that the Welsh Government has ruled out introducing new duties. The Committee therefore agreed to close the petition and thank the petitioners for bringing it forward.
Full details of the consideration of this petitions by the committee and related documents can be seen on the Meetings tab above.
It was first considered by the Petitions Committee on 23/10/2018.
Assembly Constituency and Region
Business type: Petition
Reason considered: Senedd Business;
Status: For consideration
First published: 11/10/2018