UK governance post-Brexit
The
Constitutional and Legislative Affairs
Committee* undertook an inquiry into inter-institutional working in order:
- To produce best practice principles for
inter-institutional working for constitutional legislation.
- To reflect and build on the work of
other legislatures on inter-institutional working as it relates to broader
policy areas.
- To seek, establish and promote
opportunities for inter-parliamentary working, including promotion of
citizen engagement.
During
the course of the inquiry the Committee decided to change the name of the
inquiry from “A stronger voice for Wales:
engaging with Westminster and the devolved institutions” due to the
evolving nature of the its work and the UKs decision to leave the EU.
The
inquiry focused on two strands:
Strand I: Constitutional
matters
To
review how inter-institutional relations have influenced development of Welsh
devolution since 1998. This included looking at:
- How inter-governmental mechanisms have
impacted on the development of the devolution settlement.
- How inter-governmental relations have
developed and evolved, what worked well and the impact these relations
have had on the devolution settlement.
- How inter-parliamentary relations have
evolved, the current state of these relations and how they could be
further developed in relation to the development and scrutiny of
constitutional legislation.
Strand II: Policy matters
By
building on the work previously undertaken across the UK to explore within the
Welsh context:
- The nature of relationships between the
Welsh and UK Government, how these relationships function and how they can
be improved.
- Improving opportunities for improved
policy learning between Governments and Parliaments.
- Best practice in inter-institutional
relations from across the UK which could be imported into the Welsh
context.
- The nature of the relationship between
the Welsh and UK legislatures and to identify opportunities for effective
inter-parliamentary working.
- To cover any other matters that relate
to inter-institutional relationships, including relevant implications of
the UK leaving the EU.
Evidence gathering
The
Committee launched a public
consultation to seek your views on this issue. The deadline for responses
was 5 June 2017.
The
Committee also wrote
to all Committee Chairs in the National Assembly to seek their views on how
to improve inter-parliamentary working.
Passage of
the Inquiry
The
following table sets out the dates and contents of each of the evidence
gathering sessions during the inquiry:
Evidence
Session |
Date,
Agenda and Minutes |
Transcript |
Video |
1.
Rt Hon Lord Murphy of Torfaen |
|||
2.
Sir Paul Silk |
|||
3.
Baroness Randerson |
|||
4.
Rt Hon Elfyn Llwyd |
|||
5.
Rt Hon Carwyn Jones AM, First Minister of Wales |
|||
6.
Ieuan Wyn Jones |
|||
7.
Rt Hon Lord Hain |
|||
8.
Rt Hon Rhodri Morgan |
|||
9.
Sir Derek Jones |
|||
10.
Professor Paul Cairney |
|||
Stakeholder
Session |
|||
11.
Elin Jones AM, Llywydd |
|||
12.
Rt.Hon Alun Cairns MP, Secretary of State for Wales |
|||
13.
Philip Rycroft CB, Permanent Secretary at the Department for Exiting the
European Union |
The Committee published its report
(PDF, 794KB) in February 2018. The report and government response was debated
in Plenary on
28 February 2018.
Business type: Committee Inquiry
Reason considered: Senedd Business;
Status: Complete
First published: 15/12/2016
Documents
- Reports
- Report (PDF, 794KB) - 2 February 2018
- Report - Summary of evidence (PDF 912KB) - May 2018
- Report - The Citizen Panel (PDF 5MB) - May 2018
- Report - Inter-Institutional relations agreement between the National Assembly for Wales and the Welsh Government (PDF 232KB) - January 2019
- Letter from the First Minister to the Llywydd: International obligations which bind the UK - 3 July 2019
- Letter from the Rt Hon David Lidington MP to Bruce Crawford MSP: Parliamentary scrutiny of intergovernmental relations and common frameworks - 11 June 2019
- Letter to Bruce Crawford MSP - 17 May 2019
PDF 203 KB View as HTML (8) 30 KB
- Letter from the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster - 3 May 2019
- Letter to the Llywydd - 28 March 2019
PDF 83 KB
- Letter from Bruce Crawford MSP - 26 March 2019
PDF 173 KB View as HTML (11) 42 KB
- Letter from the External Affairs and Additional Legislation Committee to Lord Boswell – 12 February 2019
PDF 386 KB
- Letter to Lord Boswell - 11 February 2019
PDF 90 KB
- Inter-Institutional relations agreement between the National Assembly for Wales and the Welsh Government - January 2019
PDF 157 KB
- Letter from the Llywydd - 20 June 2018
PDF 155 KB
- Letter to the Cabinet Secretary for Finance - UK governance post-Brexit – intergovernmental relations, 25 May 2018
PDF 204 KB
- Letter from the Cabinet Secretary for Finance - 24 May 2018
PDF 51 KB
- Letter from Chloe Smith MP, Parliamentary Secretary (Minister for the Constitution) - 10 May 2018
PDF 221 KB
- Letter to Chloe Smith MP, Parliamentary Secretary (Minister for the Constitution) - 26 April 2018
- Letter from the Llywydd - 22 March 2018
PDF 283 KB
- Letter from the First Minister - 19 February 2018
- Press release: Llywydd and Committee Chair tell Westminster Committee “Wales’ voice must be heard clearly as we exit the EU”, and call for the establishment of a Speakers’ Conference – 5 February 2018
- Letter from the First Minister - 20 November 2017
- Letter from the Chair to the First Minister - 23 October 2017
- Response from Geth Williams, Deputy Director, Constitution, Wales Office on behalf of Philip Rycroft, Permanent Secretary at the Department for Exiting the European Union - 26 October 2017
PDF 35 KB View as HTML (25) 5 KB
- Letter from the Secretary of State for Wales - 5 October 2017
PDF 38 KB
- Letter from the Learned Society of Wales - September 2017
PDF 209 KB View as HTML (27) 12 KB
- Letter from the British Academy - 25 July 2017
PDF 176 KB View as HTML (28) 15 KB
- Response from Prof. J P Bradbury, Swansea University - 4 July 2017
PDF 191 KB View as HTML (29) 17 KB
- Letter to Welsh Universities - 12 June 2017
PDF 216 KB
- Letter to Stakeholders - 25 May 2017
PDF 214 KB View as HTML (31) 19 KB
- Response from The Constitution Society - 2 July 2017
PDF 25 KB View as HTML (32) 6 KB
- Inter-governmental relations written agreement between the Scottish Parliament and Scottish Government
PDF 177 KB View as HTML (33) 32 KB
- Letter to Bruce Crawford MSP - 6 April 2017
PDF 199 KB
- Letter from the Leader of Newport Council - 21 March 2017
PDF 60 KB
- Letter to Leader of Newport Council - 13 March 2017
PDF 121 KB
- Letter from the Chair of the Committee to David Rowlands AM, 7 March 2017
PDF 121 KB View as HTML (37) 16 KB
- Statement by the Chair of the Committee - Plenary, 1 March 2017
- Statement by the Chair of the Committee - Plenary, 1 March 2017 (Senedd TV)
- Letter from the Committee to all Committee Chairs in the National Assembly, 17 January 2017
PDF 118 KB View as HTML (40) 16 KB
- * Following a resolution in Plenary on 29 January 2020, the Constitutional and Legislative Affairs Committee became the Legislation, Justice and Constitution Committee.
Consultations